Skip to content
HeartsOpenPower

When the cure is what keeps the pain alive — a perfectionist's journey out of the fixing trap

Seven years of neck and back pain survived twice-weekly physiotherapy massages, pills, posture training, and a university hospital chief who concluded recovery wasn't possible — then cleared in two sessions over two weeks. What if the endless effort to fix yourself is the exact mechanism keeping the problem alive?

AAdrian Hop
  • perfectionism
  • beliefs
  • back-pain
  • david-gorman
  • cascade
  • hop
  • healing

"The bad feelings are NOT coming from my inadequacy and my failure to be perfect, they are actually coming from my NOT accepting myself and my TRYING to be perfect."
— David Gorman (What's the Opposite of Perfect · Logic schema)

For seven years, I woke up and went to sleep with chronic neck and back pain.

Because I am a working perfectionist, I didn't ignore it — I attacked it like an engineering project. For the first two years, I saw a massage physiotherapist twice a week while studying the Alexander Technique to learn how to coordinate my body. From the Alexander work I actually started to feel a little bit better — enough that when I visited my physiotherapist, she looked at me in disbelief and admitted she had never believed I would feel better at all. That was the last time I went to massage.

That early crack of light sent me on another four to five years of relentless searching and testing. I tried painkillers, sports, posture methods, and consulted university professors — culminating in a meeting with the head of the physiotherapy university, who was also the head of the physiotherapy hospital I had been going to. We sat down to talk about my back pain. He laid out all kinds of complicated procedures and surgeries, and then, at the very end of his explanation, he looked at me and said: "But actually, that's not possible."

And that was it. The highest authority in the building had just told me the engineering project had no exit.

Then I discovered the work of David Gorman and had two sessions with him over two weeks. No one proposed a complicated procedure or manipulated my spine. No one gave me a new stretching routine or told me how to hold my shoulders. Within those two weeks, seven years of chronic back pain was almost completely gone.

Pause over that arithmetic for a second: seven years of relentless searching, therapies, and expert procedures couldn't resolve it; two sessions at the level of beliefs and definitions dissolved it.

How is that possible?

Only one explanation fits the facts — and it is the one hypothesis a perfectionist never thinks to test: what if the seven years of trying to fix myself wasn't a failed cure, but the exact mechanism keeping the pain alive?

Before you dismiss that as a metaphor, check what you are doing in your own body right now. Notice how you manage a recurring tension at your computer keyboard, a stubborn fatigue, or a life problem that refuses to budge. The instant the discomfort flares, an automatic command fires inside you: "Something is wrong — I need to sit straighter, focus harder, apply the right technique, get on top of this."

You assume the pain is the enemy and your effort to fix it is the rescuer. What if the rescuer and the culprit are the exact same hand?


1 · The Anatomy of the Vicious Circle — Why the Fix Feeds the Symptom

When a perfectionist feels a symptom — whether it is a tight neck, a wave of anxiety, or a stall in their work — they rarely notice that their reaction follows an identical script every single time.

In his 1993 lecture The Rounder We Go, The Stucker We Get, David Gorman traced this script in slow motion, starting from the exact second a symptom wakes us up in the middle of an ordinary day:

"I go about my life, doing this and that and not thinking much about how I go about what I am doing — I just do it. Then, in one particular present moment in the middle of whatever I am in the middle of, I am brought to consciousness by a 'symptom' — some feeling of discomfort, of pain, tension or the like. This symptom appears, grabs my attention and I naturally feel it as something wrong, something I do not like, a 'bad thing'."
— David Gorman (The Rounder We Go, The Stucker We Get)

What do we do the microsecond we judge that feeling as a "bad thing"? We intervene. We pull our shoulders back, adjust our posture, brace our core, or tighten our focus to make the bad thing go away. And why does that fix-it reflex have such an iron grip on us?

"Not only that, but in understanding the structure of circular habits, we can begin to make sense of why the habit of 'trying to solve the problem', of trying to be 'right', or 'perfect', or 'ideal', or even to become 'different' has such a powerful hold on us, for we are deeply caught in trying to be in control."
— David Gorman (The Rounder We Go, The Stucker We Get · Logic schema)

That also explains why the head of the physiotherapy university and hospital could only see complicated surgeries — or declare recovery impossible. When you go to an expert, you have to pay close attention to what that person is an expert of. If someone is an expert in knee surgery, or teaches physiotherapy, or gives massages for a living, they have trained their brain for decades to see through that single lens. The human brain defaults to the familiar groove; unless an expert is unusually curious, their very training makes them blind to any possibility outside their toolset.

And the rare experts who are curious enough to step outside their training — as David Gorman did when he walked away from a thriving practice to question the premise of "fixing" altogether — almost always discover something startling: what they were trying so hard to do wasn't actually what they or their clients wanted in the first place.

Look at what my seven years of back-pain remedies actually had in common: every single one of them agreed with the premise "my body is wrong and cannot be trusted, so I must control it, straighten it, and fix it." Every time I tried to hold myself upright, endure another round of treatment, or correct my posture, I was layering a brand-new contraction on top of a system that was already screaming from too much control.

As Gorman notes, paraphrasing Pogo: "We have looked the habit in the whites of the eyes and it is us" (The Rounder We Go, The Stucker We Get). The "solution" we keep reaching for is literally the next step of the habit.

Now, when a conscientious perfectionist hears that their surface fixes are feeding the loop, their next move is almost guaranteed: "Okay, then I need to dig deeper! I'll analyze my unconscious daily habits, excavate my childhood memories, and hunt down the hidden root in my subconscious!"

It sounds brave and thorough. And it is the exact reason why intelligent people spend decades digging into their problems — only to watch those problems grow stronger.


2 · The Upside-Down Map — Why Digging Down Reinforces the Pattern

Why does digging down into your habits, your posture, or your past invariably backfire?

Because our culture carries an upside-down map of the human mind. We assume that thoughts are at the top, emotions sit below them, and our core beliefs are buried way down in a dark basement called the subconscious — so we grab a shovel and start digging downward into our worst memories and automatic habits to uproot them.

In the nine-level architecture of consciousness that HOP works from, the reality is the exact inverse. The personality is generated top-down by frequency:

  1. Beliefs and definitions (Level 5) sit at the top of the personality, closest to the blueprint level and the higher mind.
  2. Emotions (Level 6) are generated directly from what you believe to be true.
  3. Thoughts (Level 7) sit below emotions — the lowest of the three conscious personality layers.
  4. Automatic habits and patterns (Level 8) and collective agreements (Level 9) sit at the very bottom — the dense outputs of the stack.

Look at what happens when you try to fix a habit at Level 8 or dig downward in frequency to solve a problem, as Bashar explains:

"When individuals on your planet label the idea that belief systems are actually vibrationally lower, that you must actually go down in consciousness to find your beliefs, what they're actually doing is heading down into the eighth and ninth levels instead of going up to where the belief systems actually are. By assuming that beliefs are down, you actually lower your frequency and get caught up in the idea of the unconscious patterns and habits and reinforce them instead of actually discovering what the beliefs are by raising your frequency."
— Bashar (9 levels of consciousness · Part 6 — Why Beliefs Must Be Found “Upward”)

Read that diagnosis against seven years of back therapies: every time you descend into the symptom or police the habit at the bottom floor, you lower your frequency into the pattern and reinforce it. A Course in Miracles states the same law as a hard rule of jurisdiction:

"Correction belongs only at the level where change is possible. Change does not mean anything at the symptom level, where it cannot work."
— A Course in Miracles (fear and conflict · T-2.VI.3)

And Abraham describes what happens to your momentum when you desperately want to get well while staring at what is broken: you hitch two heavy locomotives to opposite ends of the same train — asking for relief with one engine while confirming the problem with the other — until the whole system grinds into exhausting tension: "When you say I try to cope, which end of the train did you plunk an engine down on?" (The momentum stops when you sleep).

Which leaves the perfectionist facing an apparent paradox: if you cannot fix the symptom at the bottom floor, and digging down into your habits only reinforces them, how do you ever catch what you are actually doing — right now, in the middle of a normal workday?


3 · A 5-Second Experiment at Your Desk — Catching the Shrink

You don't need a therapist's couch to catch the fixing mechanism. You can feel it in five seconds right where you are sitting.

In Thinking About Thinking About Ourselves, David Gorman described the exact physical geometry of what happens the moment we shift into "fixing or supervising a part":

"As our point of view narrows down to concentrating on fiddling with the parts, our muscles also contract us, pull us down, narrow us; and at the same time our experience of our self shrinks up into a point somewhere behind our eyes."
— David Gorman (Thinking About Thinking About Ourselves)

Run the two-part test right now:

  1. Part one — supervise and fix: Pick one thing about yourself right now — the angle of your neck, the way you are breathing, or the task waiting on your screen — and try for five seconds to hold it right or manage it properly. Feel where your sense of "I" goes. It shrinks into a tiny control booth just behind your eyes, peering down at your body or your screen like a strict supervisor operating a machine. Feel the subtle contraction across your chest and neck?
  2. Part two — widen the room: Now drop the supervisor's clipboard. Don't try to sit up straight and don't try to slouch. Simply let your awareness include the whole room around you — the peripheral space to your left and right, the chair carrying your weight without asking for your help, and your breath happening by itself.

Notice what just changed? You didn't "relax a muscle." You stopped shrinking yourself into a point behind your eyes. As Gorman revealed in The Rounder We Go, The Stucker We Get, chronic tension was never a defect in your tissues — tension "is what it feels like to have been so narrowed for so long" (The Rounder We Go, The Stucker We Get).


4 · The Diagram of the Exit — Stepping Out of "Perfect vs. Imperfect"

Once you feel that the tension comes from the narrowing and trying, the entire perfectionist worldview cracks open.

For years, my perfectionist mind lived inside a binary courtroom: "Perfect is good; not being perfect is bad." Whenever I fell short or felt pain, I took the bad feeling as proof that I wasn't good enough yet — which drove me to try even harder. And as David Gorman points out in What's the Opposite of Perfect?, you can't escape that loop by trying to celebrate being imperfect either, because "you cannot escape from a habit by operating within the same old framework."

Instead, you call the framework itself into question — and step out of the courtroom into a place where nothing is on trial:

flowchart TD
    FRAME["The Perfectionist Framework:<br>'Perfect is good · imperfect / symptomatic is bad'"] --> STRIVE["Try hard to fix, control,<br>and hold yourself right"]
    STRIVE --> TENSION["System narrows behind the eyes —<br>tension and exhaustion mount"]
    TENSION --> MIS["Misattribution: 'I feel bad because<br>I'm still broken / not good enough'"]
    MIS -->|"Double down on the cure"| STRIVE
    TENSION -.->|"See the real cause"| REAL["The bad feelings come from the TRYING<br>and the NOT accepting — not from a flaw"]
    REAL ==> EXIT["Step out of the framework:<br>the opposite of striving is ACCEPTANCE"]
    EXIT --> CHOICE["Meet the symptom-moment without reacting —<br>'the biggest change is no change at all'"]
    CHOICE --> WHOLE["Intrinsic wholeness & tensegrity reappear:<br>'You can't fail at being yourself — you already are!'"]

Read Gorman's words on what waits on the other side of that exit:

"What would you be doing instead if you didn't get caught up in trying to be perfect? If you stopped trying to be better? Well, of course, if you weren't trying to change yourself, you'd just be the same as you were before. You'd be just being yourself. Thus the opposite of the habit of striving for perfection is in fact, acceptance. Acceptance of myself just the way I am. If I'm not reacting as if something is wrong with me, as if I'm less than okay, I'd be operating as if I'm already okay… Furthermore, no trying is needed because you'll always succeed at it; you can't fail at being yourself — you already are!"
— David Gorman (What's the Opposite of Perfect)

There is one razor-sharp question that exposes whether you are still trapped inside that courtroom. Whenever you are doing a practice, a therapy, or a routine, stop and ask yourself:

"Is this something I actually want to do?"

When I looked back honestly at my seven-year search, the answer was no. Nobody wants to go to physiotherapy. I didn't actually want to learn or practice the Alexander Technique. I didn't want to take pills, and I didn't want to meditate just to fix a broken back. I only did those things because I believed something was wrong with me.

And here is the invisible law: whenever you are doing something you don't want to do in order to fix an issue, you are automatically inside the framework of wrongness. That framework itself — invisible while you are standing inside it — is what keeps chronic issues alive. And as long as you remain inside the framework of right and wrong, true acceptance — seeing the full picture as it is — is literally impossible.

Experiment #2 — The 60-Second Leap of Faith (Wanting the Contrast)

Because you cannot see acceptance from inside the framework of wrongness, stepping out of it feels at first like a leap of faith. So don't treat it as a philosophy — test it right now as a sixty-second experiment:

  1. Drop the courtroom for one minute: Pick a recurring frustration, tension, or piece of contrast in your life right now — and for the next sixty seconds, completely drop the idea that it shouldn't be there or needs to be fixed.
  2. Flip your relationship to the contrast: Look at the full picture — both what you don't want and what you do want — and try on this exact thought: "Everything is as it is, and the beauty is the contrast. There is nothing wrong with this contrast — in fact, I want the contrast, because I need it in order to know what I truly want."
  3. Notice what happens by itself: Feel your breath and your shoulders right now. The moment you no longer see the contrast as "something wrong," you are in acceptance automatically. You don't have to fight the problem, and you don't have to try to "do" acceptance. Acceptance happens by itself the instant wrongness is taken off the table.

In those two sessions with David, we didn't fix my back. We stepped out of the framework of wrongness and saw through the compensatory beliefs that I had to control my body, hold myself straight, and keep myself upright. Once my body was no longer being policed by a frightened supervisor doing unwanted chores to fix a "broken" spine, the seven-year vicious circle stopped being fed — and I realised that I was fine all along...

Yet twenty years after that back pain had first appeared, one final piece of the mystery still remained: if the body-control beliefs were only the secondary "cure" that kept the pain chronic, what had caused the very first spike of tension twenty years ago?


5 · The Final Click — Reading the 20-Year Root Backward from Ease

I never found the answer to that twenty-year question by digging backward into memories of pain.

I found it a couple of weeks ago from the top of the stairs — sitting in the afterglow of a three-minute "gift-time" pause and the nine-beat HOP walk, where I had allowed the natural rhythm of my body to take over so completely that even my breathing was happening by itself, every cell replenishing in effortless balance.

Standing up there in that deep, natural rhythm, I looked back — and the entire twenty-year causal chain was sitting in plain sight:

  1. The root definition (~20 years ago): As a young, ambitious perfectionist, I had adopted a core belief that "I can cheat by hurrying — I can get ahead of others and force things to happen faster than they naturally unfold."
  2. The body's honest messenger: Trying to outrun the natural rhythm of reality is the literal definition of what Gorman calls "trying to change something you cannot change; a continual trying that cannot go anywhere" (On Auditioning · Logic schema). That friction generated the initial tension and back pain — not as an illness, but as a dashboard light saying: you are pushing against the rhythm.
  3. The compensatory "cure" (which came after): Instead of hearing the messenger and dropping the hurry, my perfectionist mind treated the body's tension as a new problem to conquer — installing the secondary beliefs that "I must control my body, force it to be straight, and fix the pain."

I had walked the whole chain in reverse: first David helped me dismantle the compensatory body-control layer (clearing the seven-year pain), and then the gift-time rhythm revealed the deeper root underneath — the belief that I had to hurry and strain to make life happen, rather than letting the natural rhythm carry me.

And today, that realization lives right inside the opening doors of the Heart's Open Power walk:

  • When a symptom, a wave of hurry, or a slightly-off feeling taps you on the shoulder, you don't reach for the perfectionist's toolkit. You meet the moment with what Gorman calls "the biggest change it is possible to make — no change at all" (The Rounder We Go, The Stucker We Get · Logic schema).
  • In Beat 1 (HEART · Awareness), with your attention resting around your heart, you see both ends of the stick at the same time — the unwanted sensation and the wanted ease standing together as two sides of one coin — with zero need to push the unwanted away.
  • In Beat 2 (HEART · Appreciation), because you stopped staring into the fix-it tunnel and allowed the full picture to appear, you naturally appreciate the clarity and beauty that the contrast just outlined for you.
  • And in Beat 6 (OPEN · Allowing — the healing seat), you rest in living tensegrity — active while under stretch — gifting yourself the freedom to be exactly as you are right now, while pointing your heart gently toward what you love.

The cure that kept the pain alive was the belief that you were broken and needed fixing. The moment you put down the tools and allow both ends of the stick to exist, you discover what your cells knew all along: wholeness is not an achievement at the end of a seven-year war.

There was no "my back" part anymore... It was just me as a whole being. The belief that there is "my back", "my body"  that needs to be controlled dropped and I just become me, the whole me, right here right now in the whole world.

Wholeness is what happens by itself the second you stop fighting who you already are.

Written by

A
Adrian HopFounder

Founder of HeartsOpenPower. Hypnotherapist and spiritual healer.

The practice

Reading is a good first step. Learning the practice is the next one.

HOP is taught live in a five-session course, and assisted between sessions by two AI coaches built for this work.

Join the course